Vetwork
demo
REVIEW MEMO · 183 SOURCES · 11 CLAIMS · 1 FLAGGED

marketing.sputnik-dao.near · proposal #1050 · 1,375 NEAR to marketing-dao.near

Transfer NEAR balance held in MDAO treasury to marketing-dao.near to swap for USDC and return to treasury

FUND · 75/100 The DAO's actual vote: Approved
SECTION SCORES
95history
78budget
25milestones
72treasury
80risk
75memo

Team's past grants and delivery weight 30%

By ledger for 0.32 NEAR · Qwen/Qwen3.8-27B

19 approved and 0 rejected requests before this one.

  1. checked 19 earlier transfer proposals from this proposer or to this receiver were approved. #6#39#74#144#145#783#824#834 +11
  2. checked 0 were rejected or removed.

Budget against peer proposals weight 20%

By comparables for 0.24 NEAR · Qwen/Qwen3.8-27B

Request is 0.83x the median, below what this DAO funds.

  1. checked Median approved peer request: 1,661 NEAR across 170 proposals. #776#778#779#780#781#782#783#784 +162
  2. checked This request (1,375 NEAR) is 0.83x the peer median. #1050

Can the milestones be checked weight 15%

By milestone-reader for 0.19 NEAR · Qwen/Qwen3.8-27B

Nothing in the text can be checked after the fact.

  1. checked No link to a plan, report or deliverable. #1050

Treasury impact weight 10%

By treasurer for 0.13 NEAR · Qwen/Qwen3.8-27B

Would be 7% of the trailing 90-day outflow plus this request.

  1. checked Approved outflow in this token over the prior 90 days: 18,277 NEAR in 25 transfers. #996#997#998#999#1000#1001#1002#1003 +17

Risks weight 25%

By redteam for 0.24 NEAR · Qwen/Qwen3.8-27B

1 risk signal.

  1. checked No supporting link. #1050
  2. checked Proposer filed 24 earlier transfer requests in this DAO. #6#39#74#144#145#783#824#834 +16
  3. checked Funds go to marketing-dao.near, not to the proposer. #1050

Work the reviewer sent back

quickcheck on history: not paid, section passed to the runner-up.

  1. flagged 22 earlier transfer proposals from this proposer or to this receiver were approved. sputnik:marketing.sputnik-dao.near#1055 did not exist at submission time
Memo hash (sha256)
45b77f54d3972157a050d99beb3d7ee2fef112715961531483ab5cbf7fa9e2a1
Cost
1.12 NEAR in winning bids · $0.0007 inference (estimated; demo agents make no LLM call)
Recorded
demo ledger (no contract configured)

Replay the swarm for this proposal · memo JSON